Old Dutch Tavern - Voted Best Burger in Sandusky!
Our Menu
At Old Dutch Tavern, we believe great food is best enjoyed with great company. Our mission is to serve exceptional meals made with quality ingredients and genuine hospitality—so whether you’re a local regular or visiting from out of town, you’ll feel right at home.
From our award-winning burgers to rotating specials that keep the menu fresh and exciting, there’s something for everyone at the table. We proudly use tried-and-true family recipes and offer plenty of options and add-ons, so you can make each dish uniquely yours.
Whether you’re exploring the area, passing through, or gathering with friends and family, Old Dutch Tavern is the perfect place to relax, refuel, and enjoy a memorable meal.
Appetizers
Chicken Tenders
8
Big, juicy tenders with your
choice of homemade BBQ (sweet,
spicy, Carolina) or hot garlic
parmesan
Sauerkraut Balls
9
Hot and crispy with 1000 Island dressing
Battered Mushrooms
7
With in house horsey sauce or ranch
Onion Rings
6
With spicy sriracha ranch
Cheese Curds
9
Served with marinara sauce. Choose from regular, garlic or hot honey
Loaded French Fries/Tots
7
Cheese sauce, bacon & ranch
French Fries
5
Bruschetta
10
House made from scratch - tomatoes, onions, basil, olive oil over toast and drizzled with a balsamic glaze
Dip of the Month
9
Ask your server - always house made
Pepperoni Chips
7
Whole pepperoni slices served crispy with house made garlic aioli, ranch or marinaraAdd a description about this item
Award Winning Burgers!
All burgers & chicken served with lettuce, tomato, onion & pickles. Additional toppings below. Gluten free buns available.
Choose Your Protein
1/4 LB Dutch Burger 9
1/4 LB Smash Burger 11
1/4 LB Impossible Burger 14
1/2 LB Steak Burger. 13
Grilled Chicken Breast 12
Make it a Double! 3
All American*
Lettuce, tomato, onion & pickle
Dutch Burger*
9
The OG of our burger selections. 1/4lb patty on brioche bun
Double Dutch Burger*
13
2 - 1/4lb Dutch patties (no substitutions) on a double decker sesame seed bun with Dutch sauce
Spicy Rodeo Burger*
+4
topped with pulled pork, candied jalapeños and
pepper Jack cheese
Pizza Burger*
+4
Topped with pepperoni, provolone and marinara
Bruschetta Burger*
+4
Add a description about this item
Homemade bruschetta and provolone.
Keep it vegetarian with an Impossible patty
Cheese & Extras
American, Cheddar, Pepper Jack,
Provolone, swiss
Grilled onions, mushrooms or jalapeños. 1
CANDIED jalapeños, Bacon or Egg. 2
Burger & APP Toppings
Make it your own with these specialty toppings!
Specialty Items
2
Bacon, egg, onion rings, pulled pork
Specialty Items
1
Grilled jalapeños, onion, mushrooms, or our famous Old Dutch Candied Jalapeños
Cheese
1
American, Swiss, Pepper Jack, Cheddar or Provolone
Seasonings
0
Cajun, sweet heat, classic Old Dutch seasoning
Sauces - All House Made
0
Sweet BBQ, Spicy BBQ, Carolina BBQ, Garlic Aioli, Hot Garlic Parmesan
Extra Sauce $.05
Soup
Always made from scratch!
French Onion Soup. The Best Around!
7
Perfectly seasoned family recipe. Served cheesy and bubbly.
Soup of the Day
5
Fresh, hot and oh so good. Ask your server for todays special.
Sides
Upscale your chips to these great options!
Fries or Tots
3
Soup
4
Onion Rings
3
Salad Bar - Single Trip
5
Singe Item Salad Bar
2
Sandwiches
Sandwiches and burgers served with Chips
Rueben*
14
In house brisket shaved thinly and
piled high with sauerkraut and 1,000
island on rye bread
Pulled Pork
13
HOUSE SMOKED pork shoulder served with cheddar
and a side of coleslaw on a brioche bun
- add candied jalapenos $1
Fried Bologna
9
Thick slices of all beef bologna with mayo or garlic aioli and served on brioche bun
- add candied jalapenos 1
BLT
10
4 slices of premium thick-cut bacon
with in-house garlic aioli or mayo
plus lettuce and tomato on sourdough
Grilled Cheese
8
Choice of cheeses piled high
on sourdough
Subs/Wraps & Quesadillas
8" hoagie bun, tortilla wrap or quesadilla
Philly Cheesesteak
13
Steak or chicken with American and Swiss cheeses and piled high with mushrooms, onions and green peppers with mayo and A1.
Italian
12
Ham, salami, pepperoni, lettuce,
tomato, onion and banana peppers
toasted with provolone cheese, mayo
and Italian dressing
Chicken Bacon Ranch
13
Crunchy chicken tenders or juicy chicken breast with bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion and ranch. Or spice it up with Sriracha ranch and fresh jalapeños!
All the Veggies
11
A cream cheese spread with lettuce,
tomato, onion, banana peppers, green
peppers and your choice of cheese
Cheese Quesadilla
9
Your choice of two cheeses served with salsa and sour cream
Add grilled or crispy chicken. +3
Mac & Cheese
White Cheddar Base with Cavatappi Noodles
7
Add our delicious Mac & Cheese toppings to
your heart’s delight!
Mac & Cheese Toppings
Pulled pork - $2
Bacon - $2
Chicken tenders - $3
Chicken breast - $3
Sautéed or fresh onion,
mushroom or candied jalapeños - $1
BBQ - Traditional, spicy or
Carolina
Salad Bar
Mondy - Friday
Salad Bar with Fixings
11
Salad & fixings, homemade salads and special items.
DINE IN ONLY
Add chicken breast 4
ADD BOWL OF SOUP 4
Kids
Ages 11 and Under
Chicken Tenders
7
Big juicy tenders and
French fries with your
choice of sauces
Mac & Cheese
5
Cavatappi noodles with
a creamy white cheddar
cheese sauce
Breakfast - Served 8:00 - 11:30 AM Saturdays & Sundays
American Breakfast
11
2 eggs* served your way
3 strips of thick-cut bacon or, 2 sausage patties.
White or wheat toast.
Crispy breakfast potatoes
Platter Breakfast
Garden Platter
9
Potatoes, cheddar, green
pepper, onion, tomato and
two eggs* your way with
white or wheat toast
Southwest
13
Potatoes, pulled pork, or chorizo with cheddar, green pepper, onion, two eggs* and toast
Farmers Platter
13
Potatoes, ham, sausage and
gravy, cheddar, green pepper,
onion, two eggs* and toast
Omelet/Potatoes/Burrito
3-Egg* Omelet w/ Toast
7
Potatoes, pulled pork, or chorizo with cheddar, green pepper, onion, two eggs* and toast
Hashbrowns
4
Burrito
4
Meats
2
Ham, corned beef, sausage
or, bacon and HOUSE MADE
chorizo
Cheeses
1
American, cheddar, pepper
jack, provolone, Swiss
Biscuits & Gravy
Family recipe gravy, served generously over two fluffy biscuits
Biscuts & Gravy
9
Family recipe gravy, served
generously over two fluffy
biscuits
Add Cheese
1
Add Chorizo
2
Add Egg
2
Pancakes & French Toast
Family recipe gravy, served generously over two fluffy biscuits
Pancakes
11
3 light and airy pancakes
with your choice of 2 bacon
or, 1 sausage patty
Single pancake - 4
French Toast
12
Fluffy sourdough French toast
with your choice of 2 bacon
or 1 sausage patty.
Specialty French Toast or Pancakes
13/12
Ask your server for this
week’s special!
Breakfast Sandwiches
Family recipe gravy, served generously over two fluffy biscuits
Breakfast Sandwich
7
Sausage patty or 2 slices of
bacon with cheddar, Swiss or
pepper Jack and 1 egg* on
toast or biscuit.
Big Breakfast Sandwich
9
2 eggs PLUS 3 bacon OR 2
sausage patties
BLT
10
4 slices of premium thick-cut
bacon with in-house garlic
aioli or mayo served on
sourdough with lettuce,
tomato and onion
Corned Beef
13
In-house brisket thinly sliced and piled high with sauerkraut and 1,000 island
Rueben
14
in-house brisket with sharp
mustard and Swiss on grilled
sourdough
Bologna Sandwich
9
Thick sliced bologna with
lettuce, tomato, onion and
mayo on Texas toast
Kids Breakfast
Age 11 and under
Little American
7
1 egg, 1 bacon or sausage and
1 piece of toast
Little Frenchie
8
Fluffy sourdough French toast
with your choice of 1 bacon
or 1 sausage patty.
Kids Cakes
6
Silver dollar pancake with
your choice of 1 bacon or, 1
sausage patty
Drinks
3.50
Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Ginger Ale, Iced Tea, Cranberry, Lemonade & Orange Juice. Sioux City Root Beer by the bottle
3
Coffee/Tea/Hot Chocolate
Orange Juice
Milk - white or chocolate
Mimosas & Bloody’s
Mimosas
5
Build your own Mimosa bar!
Bloody Marys
7
Build your own Bloody Mary bar! Top shelf +$2
Kickin' Coffees
6
Baileys. Screwball, Kahlua, Jamison
Espresso Martini
6
VanGoh Espresso Vodka,
Kahlua & coffee
Cham-Cham
6
Champagne & Chambord
Aperol Spritz
7
Aperol, chanpagne & soda
*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illness. Food prepared in our kitchen may be exposed to allergens such as milk, wheat, fish, shellfish, soy, eggs, peanuts, treenuts and sesame.Kitchen closes 1 hour before bar.
*All credit card purchases subject
to 3% processing fee.
Copyright © 2026 Old Dutch Tavern - All Rights Reserved. Website Design: Lake Erie Design
This website uses cookies.
We use cookies only to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience.